On October 30, 2000, Mischief Night, Jenny Fields and her sister Alexis were dared to stay in the old Crawford Mansion for the night. Inside Jenny and Alexis run into Jack and Jill, two twisted Goth/Metal outcasts with a heinous plan to kill everyone in school. Their plan backfires and Jack, Jill and Alexis die in a horrible fire. Jenny is labeled a hero. Now it's 2006 and with Mischief Night fast approaching, Jenny knows Jack and Jill are back from the grave ? with an arsenal of supernatural powers ? to finish what they started. As her friends die off, the town wonders if Jenny is telling the truth, or if she too is a murderer?